The Medical Malpractice Rundown: A State-by-State Report Card

The Medical Malpractice Rundown: A State-by-State Report Card

When it comes to medical liability laws and culture, where you live matters.

Find out how your state stacks up against the other 49.

CT – Lowering Cost and Radiation

CT – Lowering Cost and Radiation

Medicare pays only about 20% of typical charges and radiation can be reduced by 90%.

The cost of a CT is actually quite nominal – the charge, however, is an entirely different matter. 

 Aftermath: The Night Shift Season 1 Finale Review

Aftermath: The Night Shift Season 1 Finale Review

At Loose Ends

It’s strange calling this a season finale, because it’s only been an 8-episode summer run, and nearly every episode has…

Doximity’s Next Trick: Connectivity at the Point of Care

Doximity’s Next Trick: Connectivity at the Point of Care

You’ve raised $81 million in investments and your physician membership now exceeds that of the AMA. What’s next?

If you're Doximity, it's time to dream big. 

Subcutaneous Insulin in DKA: Safe — But Not Better

Subcutaneous Insulin in DKA: Safe — But Not Better

Newer Isn't Always Better

Studies show that the benefits of subcutaneous insulin over old fashioned IV insulin are marginal at best.

A Return to (Lousy) Form: Episode 7 of The Night Shift

A Return to (Lousy) Form: Episode 7 of The Night Shift

Forks! Strippers! Guns!

Once again, our characters are responding to the (frankly unbelievable) events unfolding around them, rather than driving the action.

Oxygen is a Drug— Act Accordingly

Oxygen is a Drug— Act Accordingly

Understanding the dangers of indiscriminate oxygenation in the ED setting

As with many things in medicine, dogma seems to overpower the evidence in this arena. 

Oh Henry: A Sucker is Born Every Minute

Oh Henry: A Sucker is Born Every Minute

Pharmaceutical Ads, Government, and the Physician-Patient Relationship

Though it pains me to say it, this is one time where caveat emptor doesn’t apply. 


A Ray of Hope

A Ray of Hope

The Night Shift, episode 6

This was the first episode where it felt like the characters were driving the plot.

The Downside of the Upswing

The Downside of the Upswing

You should have cashed in big-time. 
But did you?

The last several years of returns have been among the best ever.

5 Things Your Patients Might Think After Watching ‘Code Black’

5 Things Your Patients Might Think After Watching ‘Code Black’

An inside view of the ED

Code Black provides a harrowing and enlightening window into the front lines of healthcare. 

Talking Points

Talking Points

Link your vision to action

As an ED leader, you must not only have a vision and plan, but you must communicate that vision effectively…

Toxic Liquid Nicotine

Toxic Liquid Nicotine

New FDA regulations proposed for E-cigs

Highly unregulated, the sale of toxic nicotine concoctions for e-cigarette refills pose a serious threat to children.

All Choked Up

All Choked Up

Best Practices for Battery Ingestion

A two-year-old presents at a clinic with persistent cough and neck discomfort and winds up in the ED.

Gag Order

Gag Order

New ruling prohibits would-be ACEP leaders from answering questions from non-ACEP publications.

Greg Henry seldom fails to deliver on a promise. But this time, it looks like it’s out of his control.

Lock the Gates!

Lock the Gates!

Board certification is vital in EM

Last month, Rick Bukata suggested that ACEP open its gates to non-boarded EPs. 
This would be an insult to EM…

AMA Meeting Highlights

AMA Meeting Highlights

Association Gives Nod to First EP President-elect

This June’s AMA Annual Meeting proved as eventful as ever, with one exciting twist that has the potential to impact…

The Storm Episode!

The Storm Episode!

Episode 5 of NBC's "The Night Shift"

It’s time for the passion that’s been building up between the two lead ED doctors for … the past few…

Grace Under Fire

Grace Under Fire

EPM Reviews NBC's The Night Shift, Episode 4

This is the 4th episode of “The Night Shift” that I’ve endured watched. If you’ve seen it and you work in an…

Frontpage Slideshow | Copyright © 2006-2014 JoomlaWorks Ltd.
Home
Print
E-mail
Reprint
Educational Objectives:

After evaluating this article, participants will be able to:
1. Incorporate immobilization strategies into clinical practice resulting in improved function without increased complications
2. More effectively utilize splinting as an alternative to casting in selected pediatric patients
3. Recognize the value of splinting, as opposed to casting, in low-risk pediatric fractures.

Q1 What is the comparative value of removable splintage versus plaster casts (requiring removal by a specialist) for undisplaced compression (buckle) fractures; cast length and position; and the role of surgical fixation for displaced wrist fractures in children?  

A. Limited evidence supports the use of removable splintage for buckle fractures and challenges the traditional use of above-elbow casts after reduction of displaced fractures. Although percutaneous wire fixation prevents redisplacement, the effects on longer term outcomes including function are not established. Further research is warranted on the optimum approach, including splintage, for buckle fractures; and on the use of below-elbow casts and indications for surgery for displaced wrist fractures in children.

Citation:
Abraham A, Handoll HH, Khan T. Interventions for treating wrist fractures in children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2008 Apr 16;(2):CD004576.


Methodology: Approximately a third of all fractures in children occur at the wrist, usually from falling onto an outstretched hand (FOOSH). We searched the Cochrane Bone, Joint and Muscle Trauma Group Specialised Register (October 2007), the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (The Cochrane Library 2007, Issue 4), MEDLINE (from 1966), EMBASE (from 1988), CINAHL (from 1982) and reference lists of articles. Date of last search was October 2007. For our selection criteria, we used randomized or quasi-randomized controlled trials comparing types and position of casts and the use of surgical fixation for distal radius fractures in children. For data collection and analysis, two authors performed trial selection. All three authors independently assessed methodological quality and extracted data.  

Findings: The 10 included trials, involving 827 children, were of variable quality. Four trials compared removable splintage versus the traditional below-elbow cast in children with buckle fractures. There was no short-term deformity recorded in all four trials and, in one trial, no refracture at six months. The Futura splint was cheaper to use. This removable plaster splint was less restrictive to wear, enabling more children to bathe and participate in other activities, and this option was preferred by children and parents. The soft bandage was more comfortable, convenient and less painful to wear. home-removable plaster casts removed by parents did not result in significant differences in outcome but were strongly favored by parents. Two trials found below-elbow versus above-elbow casts did not increase redisplacement of reduced fractures or cast-related complications, were less restrictive during use and avoided elbow stiffness. One trial evaluating the effect of arm position in above-elbow casts found no effect on deformity. Three trials found that percutaneous wiring significantly reduced redisplacement and remanipulation but one of these found no advantage in function at three months.


Q2 Do children with distal radius and/or ulna buckle fractures treated with a removable splint have better physical function than those treated with a short arm cast for three weeks?
 
A. Children treated with removable splinting have better physical function and less difficulty with activities than those treated with a cast.

Background: Wrist buckle fractures are a frequent reason for emergency department visits. Although textbooks recommend 2 to 4 weeks of immobilization in a short arm cast, management varies. Treatment with both casts and splints is common, and length of immobilization varies.

Citation:
Plint AC, Perry JJ, Correll R, Gaboury I, Lawton L. A randomized, controlled trial of removable splinting versus casting for wrist buckle fractures in children. Pediatrics. 2006 Mar;117(3):691-7.


Methodology: This was a randomized, controlled trial in the emergency department of an academic, tertiary care children’s hospital. Participants were children 6 to 15 years of age with distal radius and/or ulna buckle fractures who were randomly assigned to treatment with a short arm cast for 3 weeks or a removable splint. Cast removal was at 3 weeks. A validated self-reported outcome tool, the Activities Scales for Kids performance version (ASKp), was used to measure physical function over a 4-week period. The main outcome was the ASKp score at 14 days postinjury.

Findings: We randomly assigned 113 patients, and 87 were included in the final analysis: 42 in the splint group and 45 in the cast group. Study groups were similar in age, gender, bone fractured, and dominant hand injured. There were significant differences in ASKp score at day 14 and change in ASKp from baseline at days 14 and 20, indicating better functioning in the splint group. Splinted children had less difficulty with bathing throughout the entire study. There were no significant differences in pain between groups as measured by visual analog scale. There were no refractures.


Q3 Do children who have low-risk ankle fractures that are treated with a removable ankle braces have at least as effective a recovery of physical function as those that are treated with a cast?    

A. The removable ankle brace is more effective than the cast with respect to recovery of physical function, is associated with a faster return to baseline activities, is superior with respect to patient preferences, and is also cost-effective.

Background: Isolated distal fibular ankle fractures in children are very common and at very low risk for future complications. Nevertheless, standard therapy for these fractures still consists of casting, a practice that carries risks, inconveniences, and use of subspecialty health care resources.

Citation:
Boutis K, Willan AR, Babyn P, Narayanan UG, Alman B, Schuh S. A randomized, controlled trial of a removable brace versus casting in children with low-risk ankle fractures. Pediatrics. 2007 Jun;119(6):e1256-63.


Methodology: This was a noninferiority, randomized, single-blind trial in which children who were 5 to 18 years of age and treated in a pediatric emergency department for low-risk ankle fractures were randomly assigned to a removable ankle brace or a below-knee walking cast. The primary outcome at 4 weeks was physical function, measured by using the modified Activities Scale for Kids. Additional outcomes included patient preferences and costs.

Findings: The mean activity score at 4 weeks was 91.3% in the brace group (n = 54), and this was significantly higher than the mean of 85.3% in the cast group (n = 50). Significantly more children who were treated with a brace had returned to baseline activities by 4 weeks compared with those who were casted (80.8% vs 59.5%). Fifty-four percent of the casted children would have preferred the brace, but only 5.7% of children who received the brace would have preferred a cast. The cost-effectiveness acceptability curve was always >80%; therefore, the brace was cost-effective compared with the cast.

Q4 In skeletally immature children 5-12 years with acceptably angulated transverse or greenstick distal radius fractures, when is a wrist splint at least as effective as a cast with respect to recovery of physical function, measured by the Activities Scale for kids at six weeks?

A. The wrist splint was non-inferior to the cast with respect to recovery of physical function in children with minimally displaced distal radial fractures, maintained comparable fracture stability, and was superior with respect to parental and patient preferences.

Background:  Minimally angulated distal radius fractures have excellent cosmetic and functional outcomes due to the unique capacity of children’s bones to remodel. Standard therapy with casting is associated with inconveniences. A strategy that is more convenient while offering comparable stability is preferable.
The secondary objective of this study was to determine differences in fracture angulation, wrist range of motion, strength & pain, return to baseline activities, and parent/patient preferences at 6 weeks.    

Citation:
Kathy Boutis, Andrew Willan, Paul Babyn, Ron Goeree, Andrew Howard. Pediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, ON, Canada. ;A Randomized Controlled Trial of Cast Versus Splint in Children with Acceptably Angulated Wrist Fractures. Pediatric Academic Societies Meeting, Vancouver, Canada. May 2010.


Methodology: A randomized controlled, non-inferiority, single (evaluator) blinded, single-center trial in a tertiary care pediatric institution. Minimal required sample size of 76 patients was based on testing the null hypothesis (H0) that the brace is 7% less effective at the 2.5% level, having an 80% probability of rejecting H0 if brace and cast are equally effective, assuming a 20% drop-out/lost to follow up rate. H0 was tested by a t-test for a non-zero difference. For the other outcomes, proportions and means were compared with the Fisher Exact and Students t-test, respectively.

Findings: Of the 100 randomized patients, 4 were excluded due to non-eligibility on radiographic review. Thus, 96 were included in the analysis, 46 splinted and 50 casted. Mean (SD) ASK at 6 weeks was 92.8 (7.17) in the splint group compared with 91.4 (8.08) in the cast group, with a mean difference of 1.4, and the lower bound of a one-sided 95% confidence interval =-1.8, p<0001. In the splint group, the mean (SD) angular deformity at four weeks was 8.2° (8.66) compared with 9.8° (8.42) in the cast group (p=0.348). Complications did not differ between groups, nor did range of motion with the exception that pronation was better (84° versus 74°, p=0.007) in the splint group at the end of treatment. No patient required a surgical procedure. 76.4% of parents and 77.3% of children preferred splinting over casting.


 

Popular Authors

  • Greg Henry
  • Rick Bukata
  • Mark Plaster
  • Kevin Klauer
  • Jesse Pines
  • David Newman
  • Rich Levitan
  • Ghazala Sharieff
  • Nicholas Genes
  • Jeannette Wolfe
  • William Sullivan
  • Michael Silverman

Earn CME Credit