Home
Print
E-mail
Reprint
alt
 
A 26-year-old male presents with severe chest pain that is ‘tearing’ through his back that started one hour ago. He contacts EMS and is brought by aeromedical transport from the scene where they have given him 100mcg of fentanyl and have placed him on an esmolol drip. He states he has Erlos-Danlos
syndrome and has had two previous aortic dissections, similar to the symptoms he is having now. He hands you a copy of an MRA report from a large academic institution with a finding that he has had an aortic dissection. His physical exam is unremarkable except for a midline sternotomy scar. His cardiac labs are normal and his chest X-ray (right) only shows sternal wires and a permacath.
 
He tells you he has a severe allergy to IV contrast, and normally gets a TEE to evaluate his aorta. The patient requires a total of 10mg of Dilaudid as well as 6mg of Versed, which barely sedates him enough to obtain the TEE, which is read as normal. He then convinces you he needs a cardiac catherization to fully evaluate his heart and aorta, so you proceed to admit him.
 
Your charge nurse calls the outside hospital where the patient had his MRA for additional records. The personnel of the medical records department recognize the name of the patient and inform you that the MRA report is forged. They provide you a published case report that you review, and you realize
the presentation and ED course in the article matches exactly the patient you’re seeing!  You do more research and learn that perhaps hundreds have been duped by him. A call to the cardiothoracic surgeons from the hospital where the MRA report originated confirms the patient has Munchausen syndrome. They also report that the patient neither has Erlos-Danlos syndrome nor has he had an aortic dissection, and that the patient had convinced someone to do an unnecessary sternotomy on
him. They tell you they receive a call from different doctors across the country concerning the same patient once a month. 
 
After obtaining all the facts, you confront the patient. He becomes very defensive and threatens to leave. You detain him long enough for a psychiatrist to come and evaluate him. The psychiatrist agrees that the patient has Munchausen syndrome, but that the patient is not interested in receiving psychiatric help. At this point, with no grounds to detain him, the patient leaves AMA. His last words
to you are, “Don’t go around spreading lies about me!” Two days later the patient presents to another local ED with the same complaint.  Luckily, one of your partners who was there the first day sees the patient and proceeds to discharge him directly home.

Physicians need to be aware of sophisticated techniques that drug seekers may use, including undergoing invasive procedures to add credibility to their story. Unfortunately, very little can be done to stop their behavior, either legally or medically. However, the diagnosis of Munchausen or malingering should always be a diagnosis of exclusion.
 
Share Your Best Cases
Share your most interesting cases with every emergency physician in the country. Whether it’s a unique presentation or an instructive outcome, we want to hear about it. Submissions must be under 500 words, and must be accompanied by high resolution images (300 dpi or higher) when applicable.
Send cases to: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
 
 

Comments   

# Director EMS/EducationAnne Johnson MD 2007-09-13 07:01
I also saw this patient at another institution. Very sad and frustrating. Spent and hour for IV access alone and had an OR on hold until we figured out the truth.
Reply
# doctor 2013-02-01 09:26
He's still out there. Last seen in multiple hospitals in central TX, early 2013. He now has pancytopenia and had given himself bacteremia by manipulating his port.
Reply
# Med Student 2013-04-23 10:07
Patient just seen in St. Louis hospitals. Has pancytopenia this time as well.
Reply

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Popular Authors

  • Greg Henry
  • Rick Bukata
  • Mark Plaster
  • Kevin Klauer
  • Jesse Pines
  • David Newman
  • Rich Levitan
  • Ghazala Sharieff
  • Nicholas Genes
  • Jeannette Wolfe
  • William Sullivan
  • Michael Silverman

Earn CME Credit