It isn’t just the patients who think I’m a bad doctor.
Based on the information from all the pinheads at Medicare’s “HospitalCompare” web site, I’m downright dangerous.
For those who don’t know about Hospital Compare, it is a site where the general public can compare the “quality indicators” for hospitals on measures deemed important by the AHRQ.
I failed to meet a couple of indicators recently, so I received notices from our hospital administration that I am now considered out of compliance with the HospitalCompare guidelines and am bringing down our numbers on the HospitalCompare.gov web site.
In other words, Medicare thinks I’m a bad doctor.
Let me tell you about the patients I screwed up on.
The first patient was a gentleman in his 70′s who started having chest pain at home. He got sweaty, passed out, and hit his head on the concrete floor in his house, causing a nice goose egg on the back of his noggin. When he arrived in the emergency department, he was still having chest pain, so we hooked him up to an EKG and … lo and behold … he was having a myocardial infarction.
According to the quality indicators at “HospitalCompare”, if a patient with a heart attack is going to receive thrombolytics (“clot busters”), the thrombolytics must be given within 30 minutes of the patient’s arrival at the hospital. If a health care provider takes longer than 30 minutes to administer thrombolytics to someone with a heart attack, the government considers that provider to be practicing bad medicine.
Now I’m faced with a choice:
A. Do I give clot busters to someone who sustained a significant head injury (and may be bleeding internally) so that I can look like a “good doctor” to Medicare and HospitalCompare.hhs.gov? If there is bleeding inside his brain, clot buster medications will make the bleeding worse and could kill him.
B. Do I perform a CT scan on the patient to make sure that there is no bleeding inside his brain before I give the clot-buster medications? If I do the CT scan, there is no way that we’ll get the results and be able to give the patient thrombolytics within the 30 minute window.
If I choose “A,” the hospital stays in the upper echelon of facilities that meet HospitalCompare.hhs.gov‘s guidelines. Doesn’t matter if the patient dies – according to Medicare, “We’re Number ONE!”
If I choose “B” I’m doing what is right for the patient, but our hospital will look bad and HospitalCompare.hhs.gov will plaster it all over the internet that our hospital doesn’t follow Medicare’s rigid and sometimes life-threatening guidelines.
I chose “B.”
According to HospitalCompare.hhs.gov, my decision made me a bad doctor.
The second patient was an elderly lady who came to the hospital with leg pain and weakness. She was in a lot of pain. We did some testing and she ended up having a blown disc in her back that was pressing on a nerve root. She was admitted and had surgery. Five days after she was admitted, she ended up having a heart attack while she was recuperating on the medical floor.
According to the quality indicators at “HospitalCompare”, if a patient has a heart attack and does not have contraindications to receiving aspirin or beta blockers, the patient must receive aspirin and beta blockers within 24 hours of their arrival in the hospital.
The brainiacs at Medicare who run this HospitalCompare site expect that I put on my Amazing Kreskin glasses, bust out the crystal ball, and predict with 100% certainty which patients I admit will later have a heart attack while in the hospital. A patient might get admitted for an infected hangnail. If the patient later has a heart attack and I didn’t give aspirin and beta blockers or document a contraindication to those medications, CMS considers me a bad doctor.
(Note: The “beta blocker on arrival” metric has since been dropped from the list of current measures – the first of several indicators that CMS apparently is admitting it was wrong about. However, the aspirin on arrival metric still exists and is calculated in the same retrospective fashion)
By looking out for my patients and by failing to be a prophet, I’m a bad doctor.
So be it.
Add these to the reasons why so many doctors and nurses are getting fed up and leaving medicine … at a time when more doctors and nurses are needed to care for sick Americans.
If you believe all of the information on the HospitalCompare.hhs.gov web site, you deserve what happens to you.
Maybe you’ll get lucky and have a “good” doctor who treats your heart attack and head injury the “right way”.