Archive for November, 2009
Saturday, November 7th, 2009

ERP here from ER Stories. I hope you enjoy my ramblings.
You might also call these three diagnoses all together “The Bermuda Triagnle” or “Triple Threat”. All I know is that when they all appear on the chart of an ER patient, you just gird your loins (like the two Roman references?) before you go in. You know it is going to be painful.
I experienced the wrath of the Triumvirite the other night – blindsided as I walked into the room.
The triage RN wrote: 50 year old woman c/o headache, vomiting, abdominal pain, body aches, and maliaise. Fine, I thought, probably a viral syndrome or the flu. Vitals were fine. But then I looked down the triage sheet and saw them. Those three diagnoses staring me right in the face. My mood sank, dreading the fact that it was really busy and that I had been really hoping for a few quick, easy patient encounters. The med list that followed confirmed my suspicions and I felt like the knife was being ground in a little further.
Past Medical History: Migraines, Fibromyalgia, Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Meds: Dilaudid, Imitrex, Topomax, Klonopin, Soma, Lyrica, Trazadone.
Allergies : Compazine, Reglan, Toradol, Steroids
It was a painful encounter. Demands for narcotics, histrionics, exaggerated wretching, and constant pestering of the nurse and secretary. I am ashamed to say, I lost my nerve. I was really busy with sicker patients and threw in the flag. I called the patient’s PMD’s service and admitted her. Sometimes you have to know which battles to fight. I will live to fight the triumvirate another day when I am emboldened with more energy.
Posted in Patient Encounters | 109 Comments »
Friday, November 6th, 2009
The American Institute for Cancer Research just released a study showing that many types of cancer are linked to excess body fat and that over 100,000 new cases of cancer each year are caused by obesity.
For example, each year obesity is estimated to cause 33,000 cases of breast cancer, 20,700 cases of endometrial cancer, 13,900 cases of kidney cancer, 13,200 cases of colorectal cancer, 11,900 cases of pancreas cancer and 5,800 cases of esophagus cancer. Researchers have also noted links between obesity and liver cancer, myeloma, and leukemia, but are doing more studies to confirm the links.
That makes me want to go out and take a jog.
Just have to make sure that I don’t get hit by a car and that I don’t get lung cancer from all the pollutants in the air.
Posted in Medical Studies | 17 Comments »
Thursday, November 5th, 2009
Why are we now testing 13 year old cats for swine flu? So what if the cat has the swine flu, seasonal flu, or just a head cold? Are we going to get out the kitty face masks? Cat paw sanitizer? Cat litter sterilizer? No more sharing milk bowls?
Then they get a positive test and the news agencies are all over it like it’s some big story. WHOtv 13 News. KCRG TV9. Pioneer Press.
I’m sure some epidemiologist will come up with a reason for testing every conceivable genus and species for this disease. Woohooo! Now the swine flu can infect pigs, birds, humans, cats, and a couple of mangy ferrets. Catnip is now a vector for the disease. Combine all of these animals together and you can come up with some thing that looks like one of those freaky “Where the Wild Things Are” characters.
Maybe I’m uninformed of the significance of this breakthrough discovery and someone can enlighten me. Until then, my response to cats being afflicted with H1N1 is “So what?”
Oh wait … I forgot.
Quick. Everybody fly to Boston and put in an application for a job at Ropes & Gray. Then just mix in some of the Tamiflu you’ll get as a fringe benefit with your cat’s Meow Mix at the first sign of a sniffle.
Everything will be juuuuust fine.
Posted in Random Thoughts | 13 Comments »
Wednesday, November 4th, 2009
As resources become more scarce and as more patients lose insurance funding, psychiatry beds for mentally ill patients are becoming harder and harder to secure. In turn, psychiatry patients who need further care are putting an increasing stress on emergency departments. Subtle financial cherry-picking of patients makes it extremely difficult to obtain necessary care for patients. When called for a potential transfer, psychiatric institutions require an informational “face sheet” containing demographic … and insurance … information to be faxed to them prior to releasing a bed. Then the fun begins.
Patient #1
A young lady with pre-existing psychiatric problems used a Ginsu knife to cut her throat after her boyfriend broke up with her. She had been drinking … a little. Her alcohol was 210. We did some testing to make sure that she didn’t hit any of the vessels in her neck and then closed the laceration. Then we went about transferring her to see a psychiatrist. The psychiatric triage nurse requested that we fax them a “face sheet.” The patient happened to have no insurance.
We get a call back 15 minutes later.
“We won’t accept the patient until her alcohol level is less than 80.”
Fine. We’ll play the game. Alcohol levels generally decrease at a rate of about 20mg/dl/hour, so we’ll keep her locked in a room for another 6 hours.
Six hours later we draw another alcohol level. It is 82. Call the psychiatric nurse back and ask to speak to the psychiatrist.
“Nope. Alcohol has to be less than 80.”
OK, Nurse Ratchet. Whatever.
Wait another hour just to make sure that alcohol will definitely be lower than 80 and re-draw the alcohol level for the third time. Ahhh 57. Great.
Call psychiatric nurse and get put on hold. Finally speak to her and she agrees to page the psychiatric attending for us.
Forty five minutes later, psychiatric attending calls back.
“Have you reassessed her?”
“Of course.”
“Is she still suicidal?”
“Right now she’s pissed off that she had to wait so long, so she wants to leave.”
“But is she still suicidal?”
“I didn’t specifically ask her that.”
“Ask her.”
“She nearly decapitated herself with a butcher knife and you’re wondering whether she was sincere in her intent?”
“Ask her.”
[Walk into room, ask patient is she is still feeling like harming herself]
“F*^& you. I’m getting the f*^& out of here.”
“Are you suicidal?”
“No”
[Back to phone]
“She says she’s not suicidal now.”
“Then I’m refusing the patient.”
“You’re refusing to take a patient who tried to kill herself by slitting her throat with a knife?”
“She’s not suicidal any more. What do you need me for? Have her follow up in an outpatient center.”
[Click]
Patient #2
Another young lady came by ambulance after hearing voices that were telling her to kill herself. There were superficial cut marks on her wrist. She had intermittent psychiatric problems in the past and was noncompliant with her medications. She also had a history of hypothyroidism. She had Medicaid for insurance.
We get all the usual labs and everything is normal except she has a few bacteria and a few epithelial cells in her urine.
Calls to several hospitals with psychiatric services were unhelpful since they all allegedly had full beds. They still make sure that you tell the story and fax them a face sheet first, but then they call you back and say that they’re full.
Finally we get a place that has beds available.
“Did you check magnesium, RPR (for syphilis), and thyroid levels?”
“Actually, no.”
“Call us back when you get those results.”
“RPR probably won’t come back until tomorrow.”
“The labs need to be sent.”
“Fine.”
[Labs sent and actually come back, including RPR, in a couple of hours. Call psych triage nurse back.]
“Everything is normal except that her TSH level is elevated.”
“You need to repeat the TSH level.”
“Why?”
“We won’t accept the patient until her TSH level is normal.”
“Whaaaat? That could take days or even weeks.”
“The doctors here don’t treat medical problems such as that. Until the patient is medically stable, we cannot accept transfer.”
“I’m saying that the patient is medically stable. You just have to give her thyroid medication that has already been prescribed to her.”
“Sorry, we’re not accepting her until her labs are normal.”
And people wonder why psychiatric transfers take so long.
We get what we pay for.
Psychiatric services are traditionally reimbursed at a very low level.
Therefore fewer and fewer facilities are remaining open to offer the services. For examples, see here and here.
The remaining facilities get overwhelmed and either cannot or will not provide care for the patients in need of help.
Patients often end up in the emergency department where they must be kept until they can get the treatment they need. Sometimes that makes days that patients are stuck in a room in the emergency department instead of getting the treatment they need.
That same room is unavailable to other emergencies that need to be treated.
The backups in patient flow and resulting emergency department overcrowding cost lives.
The new health care bill addresses psychiatric care by creating a “productivity adjustment” for psychiatric hospitals (page 379):
‘‘(2) PRODUCTIVITY ADJUSTMENT. In implementing the system described in paragraph (1) for days occurring during the rate year ending in 2011 or any subsequent rate year for a psychiatric hospital or unit described in such paragraph, to the extent that an annual percentage increase factor applies to a base rate for such days for the hospital or unit, respectively, such factor shall be subject to the productivity adjustment described in subsection (b)(3)(B)(iii)(II).’’
Here’s how the adjustment will be calculated (page 377):
‘‘(II) The productivity adjustment described in this subclause, with respect to an increase or change for a fiscal year or year or cost reporting period, or other annual period, is a productivity offset in the form of a reduction in such increase or change equal to the percentage change in the 10-year moving average of annual economy-wide private nonfarm business multi-factor productivity (as recently published in final form before the promulgation or publication of such increase for the year or period involved). Except as otherwise provided, any reference to the increase described in this clause shall be a reference to the percentage increase described in subclause (I) minus the percentage change under this subclause.’’
… which is precisely why we’ll have fewer and fewer psychiatric services available to us and why more and more emergency department overcrowding will occur.
Posted in Patient Encounters | 22 Comments »
Wednesday, November 4th, 2009
For those of you who don’t know him, Mark Plaster is the executive editor of Emergency Physicians Monthly magazine. He has grown the magazine from a little stapled together newsletter passed around between friends to one of the largest read publications in emergency medicine. Mark also a great writer and is the author of EP Monthly’s Night Shift column. If you’ve ever heard the term “don’t feed the bears” used in the ED, it’s probably from his column.
Mark has already added his first post and will hopefully become a regular contributor. Please welcome him to the blog.
Just remember, Boss … this whole blogging thing is addicting. Watch out.
Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment »
Tuesday, November 3rd, 2009
Where are those TASERs when you need them? A patient visiting his wife in the hospital began acting irrationally. Hospital employees called police who took the man to the ED for a psych evaluation. The man then left and went to a different part of the hospital where he again began acting erratically. This time hospital staff had to restrain him (apparently 10% of the security force was laid off due to budget cuts). More than one employee was injured in the incident. The man was allegedly placed in a choke hold (the hospital denies the choke hold allegation) and lost consciousness. He never regained consciousness and died three weeks later. Now the family has hired an attorney.
A three year study shows that discharging heart failure patients from the emergency department increases the risk of short term death by more than 33%. But at least it saves money in all of those government-insured Canadian patients, though.
Another ED closes. Another urgent care center takes its place.
Need Tamiflu? Go see a lawyer. Tamiflu may be in short supply in some areas, but according to the cited article, the Boston law firm of Ropes & Gray made sure that hundreds of its employees and their families got all the Tamiflu they needed to protect themselves from the swine flu. Maybe Gerry Spence was right after all. Of course, the CDC recommends that only seriously ill patients receive Tamiflu to prevent resistance, but when you and your colleagues can sue someone if they don’t get what they want, who cares? Denny Crane is on the job.
Want to visit a patient in the ED? Don’t bother. After the Queensway-Carleton Hospital was so overcrowded that patients had to stand against the wall while visitors were sitting in chairs, the hospital instituted a “no visitors” policy unless the patient was a child or a frail elderly person. Everyone else got to wait in the cafeteria so they could spread germs on eating surfaces. A secret plan to increase business?
Even Pokemon have to wait for emergency care. A T-shirt depicting several Pokemon characters waiting in line to be seen in the emergency department at Pokemon General Hospital makes you wonder just who pays for all their self-destructive fighting behavior. Unfortunately, the T-shirt is already out of production. I would have bought a few of them.
California struggles with more uninsured ED visits. Total number of ED visits increased by 15% while visits by uninsured patients increased by almost 50% at one Modesto hospital emergency department. Overall, 57% of hospitals surveyed by the California Hospital Association noted an increase in the number of uninsured patients seeking emergency care. Last year, California hospitals wrote off nearly $1.2 billion in bad debt and $973.4 million in free care – nearly double the amount from just 4 years ago. How much longer will hospitals remain financially viable?
With cuts in payments go cuts in services. Grady Memorial Hospital in Atlanta is apparently skating on thin ice. It needed a cash infusion of $10 million in September just to meet payroll and has an operating deficit of more than $30 million for the fourth straight year. Now it is laying off 140 employees and closing one third of its satellite clinics. Clinics that remain open are setting strict rules requiring patients to demonstrate citizenship and to produce pay stubs from jobs. As a result, more patients are ending up in the emergency department.
Sanctioned for coaching a witness. A Connecticut medical malpractice defense attorney didn’t get the hint the first four times she was sanctioned for coaching a witness. The fifth time a judge issued a $11,484 sanction against her and accused her of violating the rules of professional conduct. According to logic used by some readers of this blog, this turn of events means that all medical malpractice defense attorneys are unethical churls. Dang.
At least health care reform is good for plaintiff’s attorneys. Check out Section 2531 (page 1432) of the revised health care bill. It requires “incentive payments” to states that have “alternative medical liability law”. In order to qualify for the incentive payments, the laws must include “(A) [a] certificate of merit, early offer, or both; and (B) the law does not limit attorneys’ fees or impose caps on damages.” I must have missed the part of the bill where the states would receive additional payments for not limiting what medical providers could earn. Oh, yeah, that’s right. Payments to medical providers are getting cut by 21.5%. Great bill. Lawyers make more, health care providers make less. Hat Tip to Cato@Liberty.
New York jury recently awards $43 million to cerebral palsy patient born … in 1984 (the case was actually filed in 1990 and has been dragging on for the past 19 years). Don’t worry, docs. We have nothing to fear. Nothing to fear at all.
That’s a lot of martinis. Drunk driving has a total estimated cost of $51 billion annually in the US. In addition, treating a drunk driver in the ED costs four times as much as a sober driver.
Active members of the military may be able to sue government for malpractice. The Feres Doctrine has prevented those serving in the military from suing the government for the past 59 years. Now a bill to repeal the Feres Doctrine has been approved in the House Judiciary Committee. Be interesting to see what effect the multimillion judgments have upon the government’s willingness to provide health care to those in the military.
Posted in Healthcare Update | 49 Comments »
Monday, November 2nd, 2009
Mark Plaster here, author of EP Monthly’s Night Shift column, guest blogging on WhiteCoat’s Call Room.
On October 21, the Senate defeated the procedural vote to close debate (cloture) on the bill to eliminate the sustainable growth rate formula (SGR), thus killing the bill. Was that a bad thing or a good thing? That depends. In the short term, it looks like a very bad thing for physicians. After all, if the SGR isn’t eliminated aren’t we slated to get whacked by a 21% across the board drop in Medicare fees at the end of the year? The bill, introduced by Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.) called for the SGR to be reset to zero and would have eliminated the $245 billion “debt” the government owed to physicians. “What debt?” you may be asking. To answer that, you will need to put on your accountant green eye shades and go back with me to 1997.
In 1997 when the SGR became law it was intended to match the growth of payment to physicians through Medicare with the growth in the economy. If the economy only grew 3%, then payments to physicians should only rise 3% or face a cut in the following year’s reimbursement. On its face, it might make sense to some. For example, if an office call cost $100 in 1997, and the economy only grew 3%, then an office call should only be $103 in 1998. But the law failed to account for the increasing numbers of Americans who were entering the ranks of the retired and using Medicare. Nor did it take into account the increased costs of advancements in medicine. Consequently, Medicare continued to spend more than it planned, money that it had to borrow. Seven times Congress threatened to pull the costs back in line. And each time we physicians howled until they relented and increased the rates. Now Medicare has a $245 billion dollar debt, with more on the horizon if the spending isn’t brought in line.
Enter Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev) who supposedly struck a deal with AMA President James Rohack, MD. The Senate would ‘forgive the debt’– read “no cuts in Medicare reimbursements” – if the AMA would support the President’s health care reform bill when it got to the floor of the Senate. That’s why the Stabenow bill did not include a new mechanism for payment to physicians, just an elimination of the SGR and a reset to zero. The AMA had supported the House version of health care because it too contained provisions that would eliminate the SGR, increase payments to primary care physicians while not lowering pay to specialists. But the House bill had a fatal flaw. Douglas Elmendorf, the director of the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) noted that the bill was not budget neutral, one of President Obama’s promises. So the Stabenow bill seemed like a bill that had something for everyone. Physicians escape the planned cuts in reimbursement and the Democrats get to move $245 billion off the books, making the Senate bill look budget neutral.
“It’s perfectly obvious why the Democrats want to resolve this issue outside the larger debate over healthcare,” Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky) said on the Senate floor. “They’re doing it so they can say their healthcare plan doesn’t add to the deficit. It’s a gimmick, and a transparent one at that.” But even some budget conscious democrats couldn’t back the bill. Sen. Kent Conrad (D-ND) said he wouldn’t vote for the SGR bill unless its cost was offset.
Then it began to emerge what the AMA had considered giving away in the future to get the immediate relief from SGR. While the ‘debt’ was wiped out by the Stabenow bill, the Senate bill would limit increases in Medicare payments to 0.5% in 2010 and would cut Medicare by 25% in 2010.
At the time of this writing Rohack has refused to comment on any deal that had been reached behind closed doors on the Senate bill. But it all seems rather moot now. The Democrats didn’t deliver the respite from SGR. So it’s unclear whether the AMA will come through with it’s support of the President’s plan when, or if, it ever comes to the floor of the Congress.
Tags: Congress, Emergency Medicine, ER, Health Care, Mark, Night Shift, Plaster, SGR, Stabenow Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »
Monday, November 2nd, 2009
The WhiteCoat family just got back from a trip for the past 3-4 days so that dad and mom could do some public speaking.
During the trip home, we got off on an exit and were eating in a restaurant when I noticed that the young mom from the family sitting next to us had left her purse under her chair.
So I’m going to bring the ethical dilemma to you all. Mrs. WhiteCoat and I got into a discussion about what should be done.
One of us thought that we should check in mom’s purse for a cell phone and call some of the “recent calls” to try to get in touch with them before they got too far away. If there wasn’t a phone, then we could use the ID to find out where they lived and place a call to home either to get in touch with someone who could contact them or at least so they knew where the purse was when they checked messages.
The other one of us thought that if we touched the purse, we would probably be accused of taking something from it and we should just give the purse to the waitress and forget about it.
What would you do?
Posted in Uncategorized | 28 Comments »
Monday, November 2nd, 2009
Nurse K ditched the “CLOSED” sign and is back to writing … with a vengeance. May be a limited time engagement, but catch up while you can. And while you’re over there, congratulate her on hitting the 1 million pageview mark.
I was going to say that K’s new posts made me think that she had been on vacation with Cranky Prof, but Cranky Prof has had some excellent stuff as usual and has only dropped a couple of f-bombs in the past month. Must be a mix of school stress and recurrent Swoo Fline … er … um swine flu in all the students who are slacking off.
Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments »
|
|